During my nephew Mr. C's fourth birthday party, my brother Steven got a cupcake pinata. Except it was so tough that he eventually had to take a turn just to give them a honest chance of breaking the pinata. Once it was open it was poured onto the floor and Mr. C, his brother, and his cousins all had a chance to get as much candy as possible.
My nephew Mr. K got the most by the end. Being the oldest does has its advantage. Usually stronger, faster, and smarter than your younger relatives. That was sure true during Easter egg hunts when I was little.